Koral Review (Switch) – taking a deep dive

4 comments

Playing Koral left me feeling ambivalent. It is safe to say that Koral is best approached as a “zen game” in that it is a visually appealing yet simple game good for relaxation. Its dazzling graphics and mundane puzzle gameplay co-exist in discord. This game will only be a good fit for some and that’s okay.

That smudge in the middle, that’s you.

The Environment

The seascapes in Koral are incredibly detailed with a tangible sense of depth. Underwater critters will pass from the blurry foreground, into your side scrolling play area, and eventually into the depths behind you. You can tell the creator really cares about the environment and is well versed on how to make ocean plants’ and creatures’ movements look organic. This is Koral’s biggest strength. The accompanying music is chill and appropriately atmospheric.

The pro environmental messages in Koral are heavy handed, though I think this appropriately reflects the seriousness of the associated issues and hazards in real life. Text will occasional explains the impact of humans on ocean life such as coral bleaching hazards, with each new section blocked off by a cloud of polluted water you must dissolve by finishing puzzles in order to make progress.

Missed Opportunities

Koral contains no story beyond the implication that you are a sentient wisp of ocean current (or a water spirit) doing its best to clean up ocean biomes as it travels. The reason you cannot see this wisp in the included screenshots is because it is near transparent and looks like a smudge on your screen. It’s very lazy design.

This is my biggest complaint about Koral: The point of interaction with the game environment has zero effort or creativity put into it. It’s really a bummer because the game itself is lovely. The developer could have had the user play as a curious octopus or a brave sea otter. There are many times you have to carry up to five little orbs of light as part of the puzzles, so an octopus would have been perfect for the task.

Instead the player is given a plain smudge of water in a larger body of water, which is hard to see and entirely forgettable. It’s not even fun to move around as the wisp. You would think a bit of personified water current would be quick and nimble, but movement is arduous and clumsy.

Two types of the few puzzle corals.

What about the puzzles?

There are maybe two hours worth of content in Koral on the generous side. The puzzles are boring, same-y, and do nothing innovated or special. There are no abilities or skills to learn. The only additional mechanics introduced to the player throughout the game are a handful of new coral that perform mechanical functions like opening a access to another area.The others are all equally basic.

There is little to keep the player engaged in general. Nothing compels the player to care about forging ahead beyond wanting to see the next pretty seascape. All of this together this leaves the game feeling unfinished, like the dev perhaps ran out of time to fully realize his vision.

On top of these gripes, Koral is buggy. On several occasions I thought I had found a secret passage to a collectible which actually turned out to be an unintended hole in the stage design that left me stuck inside the walls or outside the bounds of the level.

Final Thoughts

Koral could have been marketed as a screen saver for the Switch at a lower price point and I would not have complained. It’s seriously gorgeous! Watching sea creatures move through the visual depths of field is mesmerizing. That makes it all the more disappointing that there is so little substance to the gameplay.

I love the idea Koral was going for and I always respect solo developer projects, but I struggle to give it more than a 5/10. Koral is not worth its $12 price point and I would suggest waiting for a sale if you like the look of the game. You can find another video game blogger take on Koral by Ladiesgamers here.

My only conclusion is that the dev must have put all of his time and energy into the art design for 95% of the project, then in the last few weeks he remembered he needed to make a playable portion of the game, so he cobbled together a few basic puzzle designs at the last minute. It’s a shame because the carefully made, lovely visuals deserved better to support them.

Thank you for reading!

Video Game Review Archive

Support Backlog Crusader on Patreon – $1 a month is less than what’s lost beneath your sofa cushions! Plus you get Discord access!

4 comments on “Koral Review (Switch) – taking a deep dive”

  1. Have you played Abzu out of curiosity? It sounds a bit similar to this game (which I haven’t played) in terms of vibe/purpose but a bit more engaging. Abzu is another title I would say isn’t for everyone, but I really enjoyed it!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I played and finished Abzu. They are honestly nothing alike except for both being underwater games. Abzu is engaging and operates in a 3D environment with an emphasis on exploration and discovery, with some neat implied story about an ancient civilization. Koral is 2D has little engaging qualities, and is about simple puzzles. Abzu is plays like a finished game and has polish to its mechanics.Abzu is more like an underwater Journey.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Blep. Typos. Sorry was on mobile. Yeah. Nothing alike. Abzu is a polished, finished game from a completely different genre. They aren’t even close.

        Like

  2. 100% agree! I find it a bit difficult to explain why I love Journey and Abzu so much, but I’ve spoken to friends (or argued lol) about them – a lot of people think they are boring (or “not real games”) and overpriced. I couldn’t disagree more honestly, but they seem a bit divisive. But good to hear from someone who also appreciates what they do 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply to meghanplaysgames Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.